We’re tackling some of the worst writing advice most people give you, what they dare not say to traditionally published authors, but not everything is bullshit. Of course, it ain’t all grand either. Let’s find out where you land on these rules.
Show, don’t tell:
This is probably the stupidest advice people give out. There are a plethora of reasons why you would want to use a tell. If a long discussion reached a pivotal conclusion two chapters ago, but a character wasn’t present for it, that’s the perfect time to summarize. There’s no reason to go through it all again when that character finally shows up. Summarize it by telling the reader, “And then, they told her what happened,” and be done with it. We don’t need to dramatize every cup of coffee, and we certainly don’t need to go into long vivid detail of the boys talking in the locker room about the chick one of them hooked up with last night if we already saw it on page. Why make your readers go through it again? Why waste real estate and good will?
If you’re writing a book about a call girl, sex could be a dominant part of her page presence. Instead of detailing each scene, you’d probably show the first one, maybe give a montage of the middle ground, and probably show it once more on page for that one client/ incident that made her give up the industry. That montage? Yeah, that’s telling. Think of how much you can accomplish in just a few short sentences! And let’s face it, sometimes summarized telling is better than the full thing.
He pulled up in a silver Porsche, the engine rumbling like a predator just before the pounce. His affable smiles, given freely to anyone within sight, obscured his darker nature, as did his opulent suit, a veneer covering the decay within. Once he grew tired of the soulless banter over dinner, he took her upstairs and unleashed his caged beast, leering with a triumphant smirk as he did so. Perhaps he thought his ritualistic thrusts should be annotated in the Guinness Book of World Records? She was just disappointed that his anatomy wasn’t as fat as his wallet. At least trading a piece of her soul might’ve been worth it.
She shook the memory away.
“Jane?” Barbra asked. “What happened last night?”
Taking a deep breath, Jane told her. <—Telling, based upon a summarized telling from before. No sense in living it again.
In short: dramatize what matters—show the moments with meaning—otherwise compress, summarize, and tell what doesn’t. Telling doesn’t have to be, “And then this happened, then that, and finally that.” No, it can carry voice, texture, innuendo, tone, pace, and it can shift the mood, too. And let me give you a hint no one ever addresses, it’s called storytelling for a reason. When you’re writing a book, all of it is telling, it’s just a matter of how you present it.
Start with action:
There are exceptions, of course, but this is going to treat it like sweeping generalization. If you start with action on a new story, no one has any idea who this character is or why they should care. You haven’t given the reader anything to go on. Maybe while the fight is unfolding, the character protects a dog or some shit, which makes your character immediately likable to general audiences, but that’s a really cheap parlor trick that Hollywood uses a lot in their movies. We want to write better stories than them. It’s tawdry, quick, and superficial, and we have to do better. I mean, they wrote a whole book on it called “Save the Cat.”
We open this new book and turn to Chapter One.
“Fred jumped out of the way of the speeding car trying to run him over.”
Okay, there’s action, but why? Why should I care that Fred is about to die? Is he the hero? How do I know? Maybe the driver is an angry father, and Fred is a pedophile. Ever think about that? I think in this case, I side with the father, and he’s the hero of the story. Run that bastard over. The above example is supplying action without narrative framing or moral orientation. Crude? Perhaps, but it gets the point across in the quickest manner possible.
The blanket statement of opening up with action is nonsensical on the whole, but it could work in limited circumstances. Is this the next book in the series and people should be familiar with your hero? Okay, that’s a pass. I will totally understand a book with action if that is a known character. “Luke Skywalker lifted his green lightsaber up to block the incoming blow.” I know Luke. Chances are, you do, too. This is acceptable. For a new author/book? Yeah, might want to rethink that opening.
Starting with action is a way to draw people into the story that takes time to build. I see it a different way. You’re starting with action because your premise or character may not be strong enough to lure me in on its own, so this is a way to get me asking questions, hooking me long enough that I’m already invested before we get to the story. That might just be my hot take, but I said it.
Open stories with character, tension, orientation, and perhaps a touch of intrigue is prudent. Action is but one delivery system for that list, but action itself tells me nothing of the world, the goals, the inner conflict, the plot, or anything else. We’re just on the go. But…if your story started a little differently, it might be successful.
Chad jumped through the store window. He curled around the bundle in his arms, protecting it from the falling shards. He landed on his back with a thud and immediately checked. The baby was fine, healthy, whole, and miraculously, still asleep. Silenced rounds peppered the wall around him, and he scrambled for cover.
What do we know? Well, Chad’s either protecting a baby, or he stole the damn thing. There’s bullets flying, he’s athletic, and he cares more about the child than himself by the way he protected it. And there’s someone chasing him. Why? Do they want the baby back? Who is the baby? What’s so special about it or Chad? Well, you’ve got to keep reading to find out.
In Red Creek, the book doesn’t open with action, but it certainly opens with tone, and you’ve got an immediate sense of what kind of book you’re about to read.
The sharp stench of a fresh pile of shit hit Maro’s nostrils. He stopped fiddling with the saddle’s girth strap and glanced at the ground behind his horse. There, a soft mound lay undisturbed.
Maro shook his head and grunted.
“Ain’t you a bastard?”
What does this cold open illustrate? Tone, crass humor, profanity, that it’s possibly a western due to mentioning a saddle. What is it not? It’s not action. True, he’s doing something, as is the horse, but that’s not what we’re defining as action.
Every scene must advance the plot:
This is absolutely, unequivocally false, and whoever came up with this idea should be ostracized from the writing community. If every scene was built in service to advancing the plot, then we’d never have character moments. You’d never see the intellectual or emotional depth to the MC, and we’d never slow down and learn to appreciate or hate that character or others. We wouldn’t know what compels them other than the plot, driving the story forward.
That means there’s no time for friendship, for love or sex, or time to grieve over someone they lost along the way. You can’t really build dread or suspense, establish culture, or sit in the decay of someone’s inner emotional turmoil if it’s all about plot.
Think back to Kiefer Sutherland’s 24. Great show. There was always action going, but there was never a time that you just really sat there and lived in the moment. It was all just go, go, go. Poignant moments weren’t a thing of the past; they never really existed in the first place. Still loved it though.
Okay, true, raw take: I’ll meet you halfway—if a scene doesn’t advance the plot, it must fight for its existence. Everything I listed above is absolutely valid. A scene must reveal: character, internal conflict, emotional stakes, intellectual disposition, moral rigidity or degradation, setting, tone, pace, or even plot reversal. These things should be addressed to one degree or another. I’d also argue, even if no one sees it at the time, it’s a great place to foreshadow (current book or future installments) or even insert red herrings.
Deep in Red Creek, there’s a small scene inside a chapter that doesn’t advance the plot forward. In fact, it’s looking backward, which gives credence to the current situation. He’s tracking a gang that kidnapped a little girl, and he’s deciding how to best deal with them. Should he give them a chance at redemption and leave peacefully, or should he wipe them out?
“Bloody work ahead,” he said, both to himself and his steed.
Bastard nodded.
“Like old times.”
The horse craned his neck.
Maro glanced at him.
“Could be Maudlin Ridge all over again.”
Bastard’s ears flickered backward.
“I didn’t like it any more than you did, but orders were orders.”
Maro hated falling back on that excuse. Sure, people cast stones after the fact, but when you voiced dissent in the moment, you found the barrel of a gun in your face and an ultimatum to do or die. Maro hadn’t known anyone to swallow a bullet, not when they loved living.
Bastard faced the front.
“A lot of folk died that day,” he mumbled into the darkness, “but not any of ours.”
The bitter taste of imaginary bile rose in Maro’s throat. Maudlin Ridge had been one of the biggest blunders he’d had a hand in. The camp was supposed to be filled with enemy combatants, and it was, but also populated with family members.
Women and children.
Maro’s recon unit swept in during the wee hours of the night and subdued the majority without issue. One person per abode. Maudlin Ridge got its name from the palladium miners who all went there to strike it rich. They built a small town, but less than two years after, all left poorer than when they arrived.
Once the main body of the army closed the gap, his unit pulled out and continued on. The massacre that happened in the wake of his departure was the first inkling he wasn’t on the right side of the confrontation. Now, in retrospect, even with just cause, he didn’t believe war had a right side. Sure, there could be a cause, but every soldier was someone’s son, father, or sibling, and no amount of violence or victories changed that.
He sighed.
“Maudlin Ridge, then.”
One of the things I love to do in my Dark Legacy Series is plant a single chapter or scene within the book that foreshadows the villain of the next in the series. It’s a thing I do. Don’t ask me why; I just like doing it. Most people miss those moments altogether. In fact, now that I think about it, I planted one in Volume III, and everyone missed it except for one reader. Not only did this Canadian say, “Oh, I really like that scene; I know who’s coming next,” but she also identified who it was, even though it was never directly stated. There were enough tiny clues that she deduced it.
But what did that scene or chapter have to do with the actual book in question? Not much. It was a masquerade for things to come. Sure, I swaddled it in the cloak of side character importance—for the setting they inhabit and their roles in that society, plus future roles they’d fill—but that was the facade to mask my intentions. What did it do for the current book?
So, no, I don’t agree every scene must advance the plot. In fact, sometimes, I like it when characters have to overcome something personal or closer to home rather than rush to the next big thing. I live for character moments, and I love writing them. More than that, I love it when I make the reader sit in it, especially if they come away not knowing how they’re supposed to feel about it in the moment. That means it will linger with them.
That closes out the first part of this series. The next one will drop the 15th of next month. Did any of these authorial morsels hit with you, or are you sticking with the run-of-the-mill road? Comment which ones you agreed with and which ones you didn’t. Don’t forget to share some of your bad writing advice you’ve received over the years.


